FEATURE TEST - Fleming 65

Presented by
  • Trade-A-Boat

OPENERS_0158.jpg OPENERS_0158.jpg
Dewar_070710_0618.jpg Dewar_070710_0618.jpg
Dewar_070710_0480.jpg Dewar_070710_0480.jpg
Dewar_070710_0503.jpg Dewar_070710_0503.jpg
Dewar_070710_0517.jpg Dewar_070710_0517.jpg
Dewar_070710_0542.jpg Dewar_070710_0542.jpg
Dewar_070710_0547.jpg Dewar_070710_0547.jpg
Dewar_070710_0559.jpg Dewar_070710_0559.jpg
Dewar_070710_0528.jpg Dewar_070710_0528.jpg
Dewar_070710_0539.jpg Dewar_070710_0539.jpg
Dewar_070710_0599.jpg Dewar_070710_0599.jpg
Dewar_070710_0448.jpg Dewar_070710_0448.jpg
Dewar_070710_0445.jpg Dewar_070710_0445.jpg
Dewar_070710_0595.jpg Dewar_070710_0595.jpg
Dewar_070710_0425.jpg Dewar_070710_0425.jpg
Dewar_070710_0465.jpg Dewar_070710_0465.jpg
Dewar_070710_0090.jpg Dewar_070710_0090.jpg

TONY MACKAY runs a critical eye over the traditional-style Fleming 65 passagemaker, but is blinded by its lack of fault in form and function

FEATURE TEST - Fleming 65
FEATURE TEST - Fleming 65

There are two words that ultimately define the quality and integrity of any product — repeat buyer. When the repeat buyer has owned and extensively used another similar model for more than 10 years, has owned a serious sailing yacht of high quality, and is a person of experience and intellect, well, you know that something is right.

The new Fleming 65 tested is the new pride and joy of a very discerning owner who has no time for inferior products displayed with the patois of slick salesmanship. It was a rather fascinating insight into the world of experience. So, too, the history of the Fleming motoryachts.

Founder, Tony Fleming, trained as an aeronautical engineer and started his boatbuilding days with American Marine in Hong Kong, famous for the Grand Banks cruisers and the less-known but very smart Alaskan 49 and 53. It is very obvious that the Alaskan style and concept left a lasting impression as his ongoing evolution of Fleming 50, 55, 65 and 75 can trace their heritage to this genre. As they say in the Mortein ads, "When you’re on a good thing, stick to it."

FLEMING FORMULA
You will never be disappointed with a Fleming — they are built to a standard and not a price. Their partnership with Taiwanese yard Tung Hwa has led, over 25 years, to the latest evolution of superior quality products. With all these boatbuilders, it really all boils down to a matter of ‘instructions’. Thankfully, the Fleming team lives and breathes the concept, design and construction of their boats. They are a top-end product. Unlike most designers and builders, Fleming and his family have cruised more than 20,000nm in his eponymous boats. The modifications and enhancements therefore come from actual use and not from a ‘cunning plan that can’t fail’. Purely and simply, they work magnificently.

Down Sydney Harbour on a blustery, grey day with sinister swells brewing at the Heads, the Fleming 65 made good at 10kts, lightly loaded, obviously stabilised and oblivious to the prevailing conditions. It was bleak.

The classic lines are rather timeless and therefore there is nothing obviously new other than the faultless finish. The graceful bow, Portuguese bridge and pilothouse styling are unlikely to go out of fashion, all being the preference for the conservative semi-retired boater who looks for comfort and safety as a priority in an offshore cruising motoryacht.

Wide covered sidedecks, a spacious covered cockpit and, in the case of the test boat, an enclosed flying bridge (a special order for the owner) all contribute to the practical and functional arrangement of the boat. Where the Fleming truly shines is in the amazingly detailed attention to every function onboard, all a process of intelligent and ocean tested evolution.

STRENGTH AND POWER
All Flemings start with solid glass construction and an interlocking matrix of frames and full-length box section stringers to give an extremely strong hull. They avoid the weight- and cost-savings of cored or composite construction methods, not to mention potential problems in future caused by delamination, by sticking with trusty solid fibreglass.

A full-length keel extends significantly below the rudders and running gear, protecting them in the event of the unforeseen but usual groundings that occur when cruising. It has happened to us all, but with a full keel one is more likely to back off and resume the adventure unscathed.

The hull is described as semi-displacement, a deep and fine entry forward tapering to rounded bilge sections forward and a hard-chine, moderate vee aft. This type of hull offers the best of all worlds. Planing performance, the tracking and safety of a full keel, and the stability that hard chines provide both underway and at anchor, all contributing to an extremely efficient and comfortable ride in most sea conditions. Not to mention excellent fuel economy at virtually all speeds.

After exhaustive tests the Fleming team determined that there is no advantage in economy or safety in running a large single as opposed to twin-engine installations. Tony Fleming finds the small "get home" engines are a poor substitute for a second, equal-sized engine. Thanks to the full keel, the Fleming will maintain her course with one motor and only a 15-degree deflection in the rudder. Twin engines also give that very desirable power required to move at higher speeds to either avoid adverse weather, traffic or an emergency situation. Not to mention the far superior handling in close quarters with the big props, big power and twin screws, plus thruster combination. Those requiring better economy can simply drop a few knots which, in many cases, will halve fuel consumption.

MICRO CHIC
Boarding the Fleming one is immediately aware (well I certainly was) of the myriad of superbly finished little details that only come with a well-founded cruiser — safe, elegant and in compliance with European CE Certification for Ocean Class.

The cockpit has laid teak decks, chunky teak capping on the bulwarks and foredeck handrails. To an avid varnishing nut, I appreciated the forward railings being fastened to the fibreglass rather than the lower cap rail, which means all the railings and capping are unimpeded by fittings that are such a pest for the budding artisan at work. This makes all the brightwork a mere mask and light sand away from a few glistening coats — always a delightful afternoon pastime for the devoted boatie.

Back in the cockpit, there is no fixed furniture and it is a huge space awaiting some comfortable chairs and a light lunch. Perfectly conceived fairleads, cleats and electric capstan winches make mooring a breeze. An optional aft command station allows deft handling with engine start/stop, gear and throttles, and thruster controls. A wetbar provides immediate refreshments. Those wishing a swim can open the inward-swinging transom door and use the wide swimplatform, which incorporates a built-in ladder that can be deployed from the water, just in case you inadvertently fall in.

A raised plinth makes a step up to the saloon and cleverly opens to provide easy and water-resistant access to the engineroom and lazarette. All the exterior hatches are beautifully sealed and lockable. All the fuel tanks can be filled from either sidedeck, with a digital level gauge and a spill chamber for the less fastidious. Or in case she burps.

The sidedecks are under cover and have similar recessed cleats, fairleads and excellent handrails. The Portuguese bridge has doors on both sides and more storage. The foredeck has a cabin-style trunk, which gives the bonus of improved cabin headroom, capacious storage lockers for lines and fenders, and a sunpad for those chasing the perfect tan. The 65’s sunpad is the size of the 55’s front deck so the whole family can toast themselves to a crisp if required. The anchor platform has a heavy-duty Lofrans winch with twin gypsies, twin anchors and chain, all into a self-draining locker with additional stowage.

The flybridge is accessed either from the pilothouse or a ladder from the cockpit. The helm station is raised on the port side and has a two-person seat for more companionable navigation. The electronics and controls are ergonomically presented and replicate most of the lower-station controls. To starboard, a U-shaped sofa and table will seat six for lunch or sundowner drinks, and one can opt for the barbecue and/or freezer to replace a portside sofa. The aft boat-deck will hold a large tender and water toys.

The test boat had an enclosed flybridge and, while I wasn’t particularly thrilled about the aesthetics of this addition, it certainly made such a huge space into a far more useable area in all weather. The standard open bridge has a folding bimini top or optional hardtop, with clear covers at the buyer’s discretion.

ADMIRAL’S BRIDGE
The pilothouse is a rather magnificent bridge, where any admiral would feel at home. With a wealth of knowledge, the new owner had specified a vast array of the most impressive equipment from FLIR night vision cameras, Boning engine and mechanical systems monitors, moveable cameras located in four locations, electronic controls with remote, bow and stern thrusters, Trac stabilisers, and every device you could possibly order. The order sheet must have been longer than the Dead Sea Scrolls. Why not though? A boat of this calibre deserves an owner who is prepared to honour the builder’s efforts, which have been so obviously done without compromise.

A dayhead is in the pilothouse along with a sofa and table — but who am I to bore you with all the really detailed little bits and pieces that contribute to such a thoroughly engineered package? Significantly though, the pilothouse is a dedicated area and not a through-passage to the forward cabins, access to them being gained from the saloon. This is important for several reasons, particularly that navigation is crucial and not to be impaired by meandering guests. Also, access forward usually involves a steep, semicircular staircase that is less safe in a seaway than the three easy centreline steps down from the saloon to the accommodations.

This companionway negates the full-width master cabins that have a certain "wow" factor in some competitors’ boats, particularly with the full-width heads and showers that do impress. The Fleming logic is good, though, as those cabins in other boats do have a down-in-the-bilge feel, with so many tight steps to contend with. The Fleming’s slightly conservative layout feels more split-level and the centreline companionway is certainly safer, being padded and comfortable to use.

Five accommodation plans are available in the 65. The test boat had the master cabin and en suite to port, a VIP cabin with island berth in the bow and an en suite, and a guest cabin with convertible upper and lower bunks and another en suite. A Miele washer-dryer will deal with the toils of laundry. The forward VIP berth lifts on hydraulic struts for voluminous storage — perhaps a hidden cellar or linen press?

Whichever option you select it will all be fitted out in superb low-key luxury with high-end fittings. There is literally nothing wanting and the most fastidious buyers will be hard-pressed to even think of an alteration to the Fleming specifications. Let’s face it, after 20,000 sea miles of testing they would have solved every problem by now. Trust me, they have.

The saloon has two optional layouts for seating, the test boat having an L-shaped sofa and high/low table to port, and two club chairs to starboard with cabinets behind. TV and stereo units, wetbars, bottle fridges and icemaker assist the skipper with party preparations, while farther forward a comprehensive galley, pantry and all manner of cooking, dishwashing and food storage appliances have been intelligently placed. Picture windows, double aft doors to the cockpit, plush upholstery and luxurious deep-pile carpeting, surrounded by luscious satin-finished teak, complete the package. When do we leave? Honestly, if you are not satisfied with all this you need to seek specialist attention.

HOLY OF HOLIES
The "holy place" of worship is usually the engineroom, certainly for most testosterone-fuelled men. If Mr Fleming got the upstairs so right, would you imagine for a moment that the engineering would be of a lesser standard? Better to get home on a well-engineered boat than shoot flares off a designer-styled sofa and as funny as that sounds so many boatbuilders focus less on their crucial systems than the styling tricks that entice less-experienced buyers. So fear not, Fleming has addressed every issue.

Twin 800hp MAN R6 turbo-diesels sit level on soft Aquadrive mounts. A special Seatorque system provides a coupling to the shafts, which are mounted in sheathed tubes. There is no vibration. Full stop.

Fuel is dispatched from four fibreglass tanks totaling 6435lt, the two main tanks being located at the forward end of the engineroom and providing extra insulation to the guest cabins. A Fleming designed supply-and-return system is simplistic and logical compared to other installations. Two Onan generators provide 240V power, with two high-power inverters operating silently when required. High-output main-engine alternators maintain battery levels at cruising speeds, even with the refrigeration and partial air-conditioning running through the inverters.

This whole engineroom space is beautifully fitted, right down to mirror-finish stainless steel panels at the back of the engines, and if it is a little warm after a long day at sea, turn on the air-conditioning. We don’t want a grumpy mechanic bumping up the bill because he is hot and grotty.

The lazarette houses heat-sensitive equipment, water tanks, watermaker, pumps, etc, still leaving a vast space for storage. If you know anything about boats you will relish the practical details that abound everywhere. Even the hoseclips have little plastic covers on the tails so you don’t cut yourself. There is stuff like this everywhere. Lifting the floors or opening the inspection hatches anywhere will reveal a quality of finish that other manufacturers can barely achieve in their cocktail cabinets. As I said, it is all a matter of instructions to the builders.

ROUGHER THE BETTER
So how did she run? Well it got better. Sydney Heads was a little nasty and on our camera boat we had played the rodeo on the waves. The Fleming, insulated, isolated and endowed with silent surefooted confidence, sliced the waves with deft ability. My champagne flute, tragically missing during our test, would not have spilled, and for this we should be most grateful. The Trac stabilisers are the best I have encountered and even beam on, nothing happened. It was as if we were on rails.

Our new owner is 79, has paid $3.8 million or so and is as happy as a lark. He is off on an adventure and will enjoy every minute of his new Fleming. He will enjoy the huge satisfaction of every delicious engineering detail, will relax in the face of Mother Nature’s nasty moods and, I suspect, it will be very hard to wipe the huge smile off his face. A few select guests and a tray of drinks at sunset will prompt a clink of glasses and the "life is wonderful" toast. Bon voyage.

FACTS & FIGURES
FLEMING 65

RUN DOWN
The editor was more vigorous than I was with the throttles and we sped down a following sea at flank speed, with 20kts on the GPS. Did I mention no noise? No drama ? nothing but straight-tracking performance of the highest ability. Of course, everyone reads this stuff and wonders whether the writer is full of rubbish or on the payroll. Sadly not. It just ran that well.

SEA TRIALS
Twin 800hp MAN-R6, 47% fuel, 67% water, 75% blackwater

RPM









SPEED









CONSUMPTION


900










7.2kts









11.5lt/h
1200








9.2kts










25lt/h
1400








10.5kts








37lt/h
1600








11.4kts








52.5lt/h
1800








12.5kts








75lt/h
2000








14.4kts








101lt/h
2200








16.7kts








132lt/h


* Figures supplied by Fleming Yachts

PRICE AS TESTED



$3.8 million, depending on exchange rates

OPTIONS FITTED
Enclosed flybridge

PRICED FROM
$3.2 million

GENERAL
MATERIAL: Solid handlaid GRP
TYPE: Semi-displacement modified-vee monohull
LENGTH OVERALL: 21.7m










HULL LENGTH: 19.8m











WATERLINE LENGTH: 18m















BEAM: 5.7m















DRAFT: 1.5m
















WEIGHT: 60.55 tonnes

CAPACITIES
BERTHS: 6+
FUEL: 6435lt
WATER: 1514lt

ENGINES
MAKE/MODEL: 2 x MAN R6-800
TYPE: Turbo-diesel
RATED HP: 800 (each)
PROPS: 4-blade bronze

SUPPLIED BY







Fleming Yachts,
Contact: Egil Paulsen
Phone: 0414 233 030



Fax: (02) 8920 1411
Email: ekpaulsen@bigpond.com
Website: www.flemingyachts.com

FINAL REPORT
If you have the money and want to go travelling then it would be almost impossible to find fault with the detailed execution of the Fleming, unless you want a more stylised, modern floating sex pad. For me, I would opt for the traditional charm of a Fleming as it will still look smart in 20 years. Have a walk down a European marina these days and spot the terrible "era" styles that now look just so revolting.



 


Want the latest stories delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for the free TradeBoats e-newsletter.